Which shingles

I am having to replace my roof and am not sure which shingles to go with. I am in central Wy and can get some serious wind sometimes. I have narrowed it to:

Malarkey Legacy 50 yr
Owens Corning Woodcrest 50 yr

I like the look of both, so is one better than the other?


I have never used a Malarky shingle, I have heard nothing but good things about them.

I have used Owens Corning shingles, they are better now…

So basically I would choose the malarky that I have absolutely no experience with over the Owens Corning I do have some experience with. :mrgreen:

Certainteed Grand Manor.