The contractor wants my deductible

So the contractor didn’t tell me how much the roofs was going to cost. He agreed whatever I get from the insurance company he will do it for that. On the contract I signed said he got the check the insurance company sent me. No extra money. I told them I’m on a set budget and have no money. Which is 100% true im so broke. The insurance company took out the deductible which was 1000 for each roof. After the roofers was done he said I owed them extra $2000 for the deductible. It wasn’t even on the contract I signed. What do I do. I need help. I’m in ohio is this legal. I’m so confused and upset. I have nothing already.

You thought you were getting a totally free roof?
You thought you didnt have to pay the deductible??
You didnt know about your deductible?
The amount you are obligated to pay…
Are you serious?

What, are you 16 or something?


Every roof I have gotten the insurance company took out the deductible. The replacement of the roof was either the same price after the deductible or cheaper. I didn’t know the contractor was charging more than the check that I received he told me that what I was given was enough. Now after signing the paperwork and paying him. He is saying I owe him the deductible I paid the insurance company.

You’ve been working with flakes. Every roof you’ve gotten? How many insurance claims have you filed?

Sorry I didn’t read closely enough. You paid your deductible to the insurance company?

Yes I paid my insurance company my deductible and I’ve had 3 claims in the past. I have never had this happen before.

Some states require a contract be clear on the price to be legal. I would never, never start a project without a scope of work and a cost listed and the terms of payment. I would have explained your insurance claim to you. Terms are listed clearly on the written contract. Your insurance policy lays out your portion of responsibility after a claim. You are legally bound to pay your deductible of an insured loss. As much of a loser as your roofer is, you learned a hard, $2k lesson. Ask for a payment plan. Read your policy. Your deductible is paid to the contractor.


In my case, homeowners ASSUMED I was waiving their deductible (which I can’t do anyways). They refused to pay, said I waived it (never did, not once) and treated me as the enemy.

I lost a thousand or more dollars on slim enough margins already.

I could buy several houses for the money still owed to me today for my work.

BUT … that money will never show up at my door

A deductible is YOUR’S to pay and PART of the amount that the insurance company is willing to pay.

Roofing is hard enough. And a new for a grand is still a fantastic deal.

1 Like

Sounds like OP paid the insurance $2000 already. If the terms of the contract does not specify you pay him anything and he simply gets the checks from insurance then you owe him nothing.

If this is how I think it is. Contractor bills insurance company for $10,000. You pay insurance company $2000 and insurance company pays contractor that $2,000 plus the additional $8,000 to equal the $10,000 contractor charges.

Sounds like the contractor is trying to pull a fast one and dupe you out of an extra $2,000.

Except the insurance company doesn’t pay the contractor. The way it works just using general numbers is the insurance company values the damage/loss at $15,000, the customer has a $2,000 deductible so is left with $13,000 to do a job that is valued at $15,000. The insurance company does not cut a check to the contractor, they send money to the homeowner and the homeowner pays the contractor.


Hmmm, I have never dealt wit that type of claim. I know like an automobile claim you pay the deductible to the insurance and the insurance pays the company. You can choose to get an estimate and take the cash minus deductible.

Depending on what is actually happening here and how the contract is written would determine whether contractor has a valid claim to that extra $2,000.

I agree and sympathize with a fellow roofer. However, if you have been burned that much you need to make big time changes in the way you do business. We do an equal balance of new work to reroof and I NEVER have anything in my 60 day column. Do work, get paid, repeat.

1 Like

Thats not what I’m saying. Im saying that they told me it will cost me 18k to do both roofs my insurance gave me 20k. And then my insurance company before sending out my checks took the 2k insurance deductible out and sent me 18k for the contractor. I paid them and then a month after the job the contractor said I owe him the 2k deductible as well. I’m in ohio and I just want to know if it’s legal. Its been over 90 days since we paid them. Now they are threatening me saying that my roof warranty is void and my roof is sagging now and they won’t even come look at till I pay them my deductible.

Amber_roz, what is the contract total on your contract? It must be written somewhere in the agreement.

Your roof sagging is prob a bluff. To put fear in you. Im not sure about your insurance problem, I have zero experience in that. But for a roof to magically start sagging 3 months after finished doesnt sound real. And if you dont legally owe them anything and everything was paid for, then they have to warranty the roof for 5 years by law.

I am not a lawyer

I do know that some contractors will play around with WAIVING the deductible to sale a job.

As I understand it though, the contractor has nothing to do with any deductible. That is between you and the insurance company.

If the guy charged 18k upfront though and wants and additional 4k just cause … yeah that’s a crappy way to do things.

You owe the deductible

she never paid her deductible the claim was paid less her deductible she is responsible to pay the roofer her deductible