This is exactly what I requested. I need to know if the mfg. will stand by thier product. If not, then I have a problem. This isnt a few shingles, it is big blotches like a 10’ x 6’ swirl sort of thing. mixed in here & there would not have looked bad.
Thanks to all for your input
[quote=“Awargoddess”]I’m in roofing, and do not agree, but I would get with the Roofer and work something out.
The shingle rep for the area you are in needs to come out first, the determine what has happened with the shingles and usually replaces them at their costs. Sometimes this takes time for them to do! Have yourself and the roofer meet with the rep at the job, you and the roofer stress to him how badly color difference is. the work it out.
This has happened to me, The Rep determined the bundle lot numbers came from different plants of manufacturing, thus giving the bad color difference. He Replaced the shingles and labor to do at their costs.
Then I was paid the balance.
I understand the Roofers point of view, sometimes this is not noticeable during the installation, Not until light effects shows it more visually from the ground level.
A Roofer always wants paid when the job is done, he or she has obligations to pay their people and etc…
Determine an amunt Fair to both of you, hold it ,get roof replaced, pay him.
Everyone is happy, and you have the quality of job You expected.