I had someone come out and take a look at my porch roof which I intended to replace in a couple weeks. My gut is telling me what is being proposed will not last. The contractor proposed a 2 ply gaf system whereas my dad is saying torch down. I want to bring others out to provide more estimates but wanted to seek out unbiased professional guidance as to the proper way to fix it.
I have researched Flintlastic Base 20T and GTA as a possible solution, Polyglass’s Polyflex G as a back up, and IB Roofing Systems which is my least favorite option because of the overall look. Picture is included below and thank you in advance.