My living room recently showed a leak after a heavy rain. I would like opinions on whether I should repair the leak, or have underlayment replaced for the entire roof.
Here are some facts
-26 year old roof with strong concrete shingles and a single layer of 30 lb paper
-Live in Southern California…not much rain
-Had the roof inspected 5 years ago; inspector said the paper was in good condition
-New underlayment estimates are coming in around $14k; repair about $2,500
-Only one person in my neighborhood has had their roof underlayment replaced
What do you think I should do?