Certainteed is my vote.
But based on good reviews of malarky by axiom
And others, i would give them the business.
I dont have those available to me.
Seems like you might pay a little extra for shipping.
I wouldnt let that sway me if i thought they were superior.
What i am disappointed with Certainteed landmarks
Is their algae that starts taking over the roof at Year 6.
But their shingle construction over all is superior!
Next choice would be Atlas.
Because They warranty against Algae/ streaking for life.
And i believe it, because i have some roofs i installed with atlas before they improved their shingles with the lifetime streaking warranty and they Still look good
I like the beauty and construction of the Certainteed shingle better so that is why i choose them
But i am starting to lose patience about them not improving their streaking issue after year 6 like clock work.
I wouldnt install Durations if they were free.
Really, Really bad design.
And i am SURE it is the same way across the country.
I Wanted to love them but i have seen for myself
On my own roofs
that they are leaky.
Probably the only leaky shingle in the industry.
Do not even pay attention to the price
difference between Certainteed, Malarky, Atlas.
Choose the one you believe to be the best.
The price difference between them is nothing in my mind.